onsdag 11. november 2015

Value in oil stocks? Yes according to Schiller P/E, however you need to be a believer

According to the infamous Shiller P/E matrix, the only sector worth investing in these days (at least in the US) is the energy sector. The Shiller P/E for the sector is currently 11.9x vs. 26.3 for the S&P 500 as a whole. What a significant discount or what?

There is only one problem with the Shiller P/E, it will only work as a buy signal if the depressed earnings of the energy companies make a comeback, and this will only happen if the oil price moves back to previously seen levels within a reasonable time-frame. Stating that energy stocks are cheap due to a low Shiller P/E is the same as making the statement that the oil price will make a comeback.

Shiller P/E by sector:


                                  Source: Gurufocus

Oil prices and energy stocks track each other like no other, and you have to be a believer that oil demand will outstrip oil supply at some point during the near future in order to trust energy stocks as a value play. From the looks of it, oil stocks have not strayed away from their normal close tracking of the oil price during the current downturn. 

Oil price vs. energy stocks:

                               Source: Gurufocus

Disclosure: I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving any compensation for it.
Blogglistenhits